The Power of "Could": A Simple Shift That Changes Everything
I'll be honest—I picked this up from a YouTube video, but it stuck with me.
I’ll be honest—I picked this up from a YouTube video, but it stuck with me. It was a golf video (because, let’s be real, that’s about all I watch). A student lined up a putt, took his shot, and missed. Frustrated, he said, “Ah… I should have made that.” Without missing a beat, the coach jumped in, “I don’t want you saying that anymore. Why should you have made it? Instead, every time you step up to the ball, I want you thinking, I could make this putt. Stop putting so much pressure on yourself.”
Have you ever done this to yourself? I know I have.
We pile up these “shoulds” like bricks, building walls of expectation that keep us trapped. I should be a better parent. I should be more disciplined. I should have figured this out by now.
But what if I told you that swapping out just one word could change everything?
The Trap of “Should”
“Should” is a demanding taskmaster. It points fingers, whispers accusations, and reminds you of all the ways you’re falling short. It doesn’t invite growth—it enforces guilt.
Think about it:
- “I should be more patient.” (Translation: I’m failing at patience.)
- “I should have known better.” (Translation: I’m not wise enough.)
- “I should be further along.” (Translation: I’m behind, and it’s my fault.)
The problem with “should” is that it’s loaded with expectation but empty of grace. It assumes there’s only one right path and that you’ve somehow missed it. It locks you into a fixed mindset—where the only options are success or failure.
But there’s another way.
The Freedom of “Could”
Now, try swapping should for could.
- “I could be more patient.” (Translation: There’s an opportunity to grow in patience.)
- “I could learn from this mistake.” (Translation: I’m not stuck; I’m growing.)
- “I could take steps forward.” (Translation: I have options, not just obligations.)
Do you feel the difference? Could opens doors. It shifts the weight from pressure to possibility. It reminds us that growth is a journey, not a finish line we’ve already missed.
Where should shames, could invites.
Rewriting Your Inner Script
This isn’t just about language—it’s about how we see ourselves. And let’s be honest, how we talk to ourselves matters. If we want to grow as leaders, parents, pastors, and friends, we need to pay attention to the words shaping our mindset.
Here’s a simple practice to start:
1. Notice Your “Shoulds”
Keep a mental log (or jot them down in your phone) for a day. Where does “should” show up in your thoughts?
- “I should have responded better in that meeting.”
- “I should be more present with my kids.”
- “I should have more faith.”
2. Ask the Hard Question
When you catch a should, pause and ask: Who says?
- Is this an expectation I’ve placed on myself?
- Did I absorb this from someone else’s standard?
- Is this pressure leading me toward growth or just making me feel stuck?
3. Rewrite It With “Could”
Now, reframe the thought with could.
- “I could learn how to handle tough meetings better.”
- “I could put my phone away for the next hour and be fully present.”
- “I could lean into God’s grace instead of beating myself up.”
4. Watch What Happens
When we start replacing should with could, we begin to move forward with more freedom. We don’t just trade stress for optimism—we step into possibility, creativity, and faith.
Real-Life Shifts
This shift isn’t just for our inner dialogue—it changes how we lead, how we parent, and how we navigate the pressure of ministry.
In Leadership:
- Should: “I should have all the answers for my team.”
- Could: “I could create space for collaboration and trust others’ insights.”
In Parenting:
- Should: “I should be a perfect example for my kids.”
- Could: “I could show them what growth and grace look like by admitting when I’m wrong.”
In Faith:
- Should: “I should be stronger in my belief.”
- Could: “I could bring my doubts and struggles to God, knowing He meets me where I am.”
The Biblical Connection
Scripture is full of could moments—where people had every reason to stay stuck in should thinking but chose to step into possibility instead.
- Moses should have been disqualified because of his past, but he could step into God’s calling.
- Peter should have been written off after denying Jesus, but he could be restored and lead the church.
- Paul should have been too broken by his past, but he could walk in grace and change the world.
God is far more interested in what we could become than in punishing us for where we think we should be.
The One-Word Challenge
For the next week, try this: every time you catch a should, replace it with could.
See how it changes your thinking. See how it affects your stress levels, your leadership, your parenting, and your faith.
One word can make all the difference.
And the best part? You could start right now.